Skip to content

Twice-elected South Lake Tahoe council member who served as mayor admits stealing nearly $390,000 from the church she kept the books for

By David · · About the editor

South Lake Tahoe, Nevada (21560976622)
Photo: Ken Lund from Reno, Nevada, USA, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Tamara Le Ann Wallace was elected to the South Lake Tahoe, California City Council twice, and her council colleagues selected her to serve as the city’s mayor, most recently in 2025. The whole time she held that title, she was also the bookkeeper and an authorized check signer for a small nonprofit church, and prosecutors say she was quietly draining its bank account.

On October 29, 2026, Wallace pleaded guilty in federal court to one count of wire fraud, according to local reporting on the case. She is 56 years old.

Two jobs, one trust

Wallace served two separate terms on the South Lake Tahoe City Council, after being elected by voters in 2018 and 2022. The city’s mayor is not a separately elected position; instead, South Lake Tahoe’s five-member City Council votes among themselves to select who holds the title, and Wallace’s colleagues chose her for that role, including as recently as 2025. During that same period, she worked as the bookkeeper for Lake Tahoe Community Presbyterian Church, where she also had signing authority on the church’s checking account.

Federal prosecutors say the scheme at the church ran from roughly April 2019 through September 2025, more than six years, according to KTVU’s coverage of the plea.

The numbers

According to prosecutors, Wallace wrote herself approximately $360,000 in checks drawn on the church’s account. She also made about $31,000 in unauthorized electronic transfers. Combined, that puts the total close to $390,000 taken from the congregation, as detailed in South Tahoe Now’s report.

Investigators say many of the checks were disguised with vague notations that gave no real explanation for the payment. One example cited in reporting: a $7,500 check dated September 5, 2025, marked only “Reimb.” There was reportedly nothing behind it to reimburse.

How it was discovered

The church did not find out about the missing money until it terminated Wallace’s employment on September 26, 2025. Only after she was let go did the extent of the shortfall come to light.

The financial hole reportedly forced the congregation to cut programming, take out loans, and pay late fees on overdue bills, per California Globe’s account of the case.

The resignation

Wallace resigned from the South Lake Tahoe City Council and her position as mayor on October 13, 2025. She announced it by sending local media a letter admitting to the theft and describing a mental-health crisis, according to the News 3 LV report.

Worth noting as a matter of timeline: the public admission came after she had already been terminated from the church job and the theft had already been uncovered.

What comes next

Wire fraud carries a statutory maximum of 20 years in federal prison and a $250,000 fine. Wallace’s actual sentence has not yet been determined. Sentencing is currently scheduled for January 14, 2027.

For now, the public record shows a guilty plea, a resignation, and a congregation still working to recover from a shortfall left by the person they’d trusted to manage their books, the same person voters twice elected to the council that put her in position to be chosen as mayor.

Read the full case file and more like it at themoraldecayindex.com. What’s your verdict on Tamara Wallace? Leave it in the comments.

Track the gap between what institutions promise and what they deliver with the Moral Consistency Journal. Keep reading at themoraldecayindex.com, and find the books behind the work in our Bookshop store.

Scroll to Top