Skip to content

Fired deputy indicted in New Mexico DWI-fixing scandal that buried hundreds of drunk driving cases

By David · · About the editor

Bernalillo County New Mexico Courthouse
Photo: AllenS, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

A federal grand jury has indicted a former Bernalillo County Sheriff’s Office deputy, accusing him of taking bribes to make drunk-driving cases disappear. The charge adds a new name to a corruption scandal that New Mexico prosecutors say stretches back to the late 1990s.

Paul Jessen Jr. was indicted on November 4, 2026, on one count of conspiracy to commit interference with commerce by extortion under color of official right. The charge carries up to 20 years in prison.

Jessen worked on BCSO’s DWI unit starting in 2016. According to prosecutors, he handled eight drunk-driving arrests connected to defense attorney Thomas Clear III between 2016 and 2019. All but one of those eight cases were dismissed.

Gifts for dismissed cases

The indictment alleges Jessen and a senior BCSO deputy accepted bribes from Clear in exchange for killing DWI cases. The alleged payoffs included a Craftsman tool chest, a Pit Boss smoker, a flat-screen television, and free legal representation.

These were deputies sworn to enforce drunk-driving laws and protect the public. Prosecutors say at least one of them traded that authority for a smoker and a TV.

Bernalillo County Sheriff John Allen terminated Jessen on September 17, 2026. The firing came two months after a federal jury convicted Jessen in a separate case on charges of conspiracy to obstruct justice, obstruction of justice, and making false statements, stemming from allegations he tipped off targets of a DEA investigation; that conviction carries a potential sentence of up to 65 years.

A scandal decades in the making

Jessen’s case is the newest chapter in a corruption investigation that prosecutors and local reporting trace back to the late 1990s. The scheme centered on defense attorneys paying police officers to tank drunk-driving cases, letting defendants walk while attorneys collected fees.

Thomas Clear III has already pleaded guilty, along with his paralegal and investigator Ricardo Mendez and a second defense attorney, Rudy Chavez. On the law enforcement side, nine Albuquerque Police Department officers and a second Bernalillo County deputy, Jeffrey Hammerel, have also pleaded guilty to racketeering and extortion-related charges tied to the same scheme.

The fallout has reached far beyond the courtroom convictions. The Bernalillo County District Attorney’s Office has dismissed nearly 200 DWI cases filed by officers implicated in the scheme. Each of those dismissals was a drunk-driving arrest that never faced a day of accountability, spread across three separate law enforcement agencies.

This is interpretation, not established fact: a scandal spanning two and a half decades raises hard questions about how the arrangement went undetected for so long inside multiple agencies.

Jessen has not yet entered a plea in the DWI case. The case remains an active federal prosecution.

Read more Case Files and share your own verdict at themoraldecayindex.com. What do you think happened here, and what should happen next?

Track the gap between what institutions promise and what they deliver with the Moral Consistency Journal. Keep reading at themoraldecayindex.com, and find the books behind the work in our Bookshop store.

Scroll to Top